Barber, a political theorist whose 1995 book, jihad vs. Final religion culture and globalization ndu international. Barbers call for civil societies, for citizenship, to counter both transnational corporatism and parochial nationalism hasnt lost any of its power. The struggle that exists between countries that wish to conform to global considerations and national groups that desire independence may further splinter fragile countries. The organizers had seen in barbers book a framework within which to locate matters of social justice alongside the broad and dynamic domestic and. Just beyond the horizon of current events lie two possible political futuresboth bleak, neither democratic. How globalism and tribalism are reshaping the world is a book by american political scientist benjamin barber, in which he puts forth. Jihad delivers different set of values than mcworld. Mcworld questions and answers discover the community of teachers, mentors and students just like you that can answer any question you might have on jihad vs. How the planet is both falling apart and coming together and what this means for democracy 1995. How globalism and tribalism are reshaping the world by benjamin r. If you had to choose between living in a mcworld or a world of jihad.
Barber offers a penetrating analysis of the central conflict of our times. Mcworld, or the globalization of politics four imperatives make lpthe dynamic of mcwodd. The only hope, he says, is democracy, and between the equally malign forces of jihad and mcworld, the odds for it arent too good. His title refers to what he sees as the two premier global trends of our day, movements that are, respectively, reducing the world to intractable fragments and. How globalism and tribalism are re shaping the world barber, benjamin isbn. It is my hypothesis that the fundamental source of conflict in this new world will not be primarily ideological or primarily economic. However in opposition to this it can easily be contested that both jihad and mcworld, in actual fact, cultivate democracy.
Mcworld is a groundbreaking work, an elegant and illuminating analysis of the central conflict of our times. In an interview conducted in february, philanthropy news digest spoke with political scientist benjamin barber, author of the international bestseller jihad vs. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. Mcworld, based on a 1992 article in the atlantic monthly, barber turns from the intellectual threats to his vision of democracy to the socioeconomic ones. It looks at the issue of democracy and how neither terrorism nor corporate globalization necessarily support democracy. Industrial revolution, and the technological advances of the twentieth century. Mcworld the following article from the atlantic online, has been reposted here. The questions were in italian and the answers in french. On the other hand, the mcworld can best describe the conditions in the u. The mc world is the more formal way of life in the u. Mcworld, presciently analyzed the socioeconomic forces leading to the.
In the essay, jihad vs mcworld, barber suggests that there is a complete failure by both jihad and mcworld to promote democracy in any form. Amidst this confusion and difficulty, i continue to think that benjamin barbers characterization of the clash of civilizations as jihad vs. During president clintons historic 1994 visit to eastern. If ever a commentator on the world scene was to be allowed the dubious privilege of saying i told you so on september 11 2001, it was. According to the professors realpolitik, mcworld means not merely worldwide fast food but all capitalist buccaneering, global marketeering, cyberspace, megamergers, and international corporate incest aimed at. Mcworld, about 911, the continuing threat from global terrorist organizations, the efficacy of military action against iraq in response to that threat, and democracy as an antidote to. Barbers argument in jihad vs mcworld mcworld, usa mcworld, malaysia jihad, pakistan. Although in the west it is sometimes erroneously translated as holy war and understood as referring exclusively to military combat, islamic texts yield a broader array of meanings connected to moral and ethical struggles. The terrorist attacks of september 11 did without a doubt change the world. Article pdf available in journal of education culture and society december 2010 with. It delivers peace, prosperity, and relative unityif at the cost of independence, community, and identity which is. Barber is the whitman professor of political science at rutgers university. Mcworld, benjamin barber takes a view of the new economic world as it relates to those cultures that are hanging on to traditional values. One of the most important questions that barber tries to answer in jihad vs.
This book elaborates a thesis barber first introduced in an article in the atlantic and which. The first is a retribalization of large swaths of humankind by war and bloodshed. Imprimer l article the terrorist attacks of september 11 did without a doubt change the world forever, but they failed to change the ideological viewpoint of either the left or the right in any significant way. Various definitions of democracy have contributed to the struggle. Mcworld does manage to look pretty seductive in a world obsessed with jihad. Mcworld, presciently analyzed the socioeconomic forces leading to the sept. The following article is a summary of jihad, mc world, and their characteristics after september 11. Mcworld term sometimes used to describe the spreading of mcdonalds restaurants throughout the world as the result of globalization, and more generally to describe the effects of international mcdonaldization of services and commercialization of goods and services as an element of globalization as a whole.
Americas current conflict with islamic fundamentalism has breathed new life into several nearly forgotten geopolitical metaphors, including samuel p. Mcworld and other theories article pdf available in journal of education culture and society december 2010 with 289 reads how we measure reads. Barber 1992 huntingtons clash of civilizations in the 1993 foreign affairs article, huntington writes. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The war in the nations between the two different cultures can be called a modern day jihad.
Jihad and mcworld in a changing world, there are two known political futures. Huntingtons notion of a clash of civilizations, robert d. Barber j ust beyond the horizon of current events lie two possible political futures both bleak, neither democratic. Barber is the first distinguished senior fellow at the fordham university urban consortium, and the president and founder of the interdependence movement as well as. Barbers most recent books are strong democracy 1984. Jihad refers to a retribalization of large swaths of humankind by war and bloodshed. Mcworld to create the theme of a conference we called between jihad and mcworld. In a groundbreaking work, political scientist benjamin r.
After september 11, plenty would like to ring the death knell on the anticorporate movement, along with the twin tower terrorists. Considering it was written in 1992, do you think this article is still relevant in todays world. Between mcworld and jihad globalisation the guardian. During president clintons historic 1994 visit to eastern europe and russia, he often. Read this philosophy essay and over 89,000 other research documents. There is a basic conflict between these two ideologies. Jihad vs mcworld the two axial principles of our age tribalism and globalism clash at every point except one. These diametrically opposed but strangely intertwined forces are tearing apartand bringing togetherthe world as we know it, undermining democracy and the nationstate on which it depends. I reread jihad vs mcworld to see if was still relevant after so many years and i found that it is, in fact, more relevant than ever. Kaplans theory of a coming anarchy, and benjamin barbers juxtaposition of jihad vs. What question is benjamin barber trying to answer in jihad vs. Democracy is being threatened, says benjamin barber, by a rampant, homogenizing, valueless capitalism mcworld on one hand and by fragmenting, fundamentalist ideologies jihad on the other.
Barber from the january 21, 2002 issue the terrorist attacks of september 11 did without a doubt change the world forever, but they failed to change the ideological viewpoint of either the left or the right in any signi. Barber, the main discussion is about the comparison of the jihad world of a threatened lebanonization of national states in which culture is pitted against culturebarber, 1992, page 1 to the mcworld of economic and political globalization. How globalism and tribalism are reshaping the world is a 1995 book by american political scientist benjamin barber, in which he puts forth a theory that describes the struggle between mcworld globalization and the corporate control of the political process and jihad arabic term for struggle, here modified to mean tradition and traditional values, in the form of. Mcworld unless otherwise noted in his book, jihad vs. To understand this contradiction we must first understand the meaning. Like hollywood is mcworlds storyteller, and it inculcates secularism, passivity, consumerism, vicariousness, impulse buying, and an accelerated pace of life, not as a result of its overt themes and explicit story lines but by virtue of what hollywood is and how its products are consumed. Mcworld the two axial principles of our agetribalism and globalismclash at every point except one.
132 107 627 952 1424 703 1477 738 749 1226 511 655 819 753 1550 456 275 1299 150 997 8 237 1251 1051 891 759 668 676 1249 335 1376 390 669 591 916